The Montaigne Fallacy

“The Leitmotiv [i.e., an often repeated theme] of social philosophy up to the emergence of economics was: The profit of one man is the damage of another; no man profits but by the loss of others.  This is not a philosophy of social cooperation, but of dissociation and social disintegration.  For the sake of expediency, we call this doctrine after its proponent, essayist Michel Eyquem de Montaigne (1533-92).  In the light of this Montaigne fallacy, human intercourse cannot consist in anything but the spoliation of the weaker by the stronger.”

–Ludwig von Mises. Economics as a Bridge for Interhuman Understanding

Comments

  1. [...] there was economics, there was the Montaigne Fallacy. Many still believe [...]

  2. gangrenebacks says:

    That is only even slightly possible as long as the Pile Of Stuff (POS, to quote Obama) remains constant. History has certainly disproved that.

  3. [...] often identified as the “zero-sum” fallacy. Ludwig von Mises termed this idea the “Montaigne Fallacy”:The Leitmotiv [i.e., an often repeated theme] of social philosophy up to the emergence of economics [...]

Leave a Reply